e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented, Coffee

I love this eye liner!! I am ordering more!! It goes on easy, and it doesn't keep breaking when you apply it! Thanks!

The perfect eye liner! Its so hard to find one that doesn’t smudge ☺️

I really like this eyeliner. It goes on smoothly and doesn’t smudge after the 30 seconds it needs to set, however, it will still come off nicely with micellar water if it doesn’t look as planned but, it doesn’t come off when rubbed. The reason I gave 4 stars is because when you turn the tube to bring out the product, it feels very loose and sometimes the product moves as you’re using it. I don’t know if I got a dud or if this is how it usually is but, I guess I’ll find out when I order it again.

I love having this as one of my subscriptions, because I never have to worry about running out.

This brand is a go to now. This is the only brand that truly stayes on and when I want to take it off it comes off. I won't waste money on any other brand no matter the price. The color lasts and stays sharp and visable. Easy to put on, no tugging, it's soft. Not sure about waterproof but I sweat.

This isn't bad, but I am slightly disappointed; my eye liner pencil was new and not damaged. I found it a bit dry and, although it said it could be used on the waterline, I find it dry, thick and slightly uncomfortable on my sensitive eyes. It doesn't run or flake, the colour is as expected. I do use it, but if I had a pencil with a finer tip and a nicer feel, I would throw this away. Mine might be a bit old, by some fluke, and my eyes are probably more sensitive than average. This pencil could work very well for some, especially people who want a thicker line along the external lash line (although don't expect to blend it out a lot). It is doing the job when I absolutely need something, though. I was just hoping for a slightly different formula.

Love this product...I have tried many eyeliners over the year...for the price this is the best...it goes on smooth and stays on without smudging....and you can't beat the price....great value for the money.

I love it, it’s exactly as described by seller.